Probiotic Bacteria: A Promising drug in Cancer Prevention and Therapy

 

Dr.Ashis Kumar Ghosh 

                    MBBS, DCH. MD

Assistant Professor Paediatric Hematology and Oncology 

National Institute of Cancer Research and Hospital 

Telephone number : 8801712685509 

Health and Hope Hospital 

152/2/G, Green Road,Panthapath, Dhaka-1205, Bangladesh 

For Appointment: 01611131253, 01678131252

Sunday and Wednesday 2-5 pm. (Room no-311)

Web. https://child-cancer-care-bangladesh5.cms.webnode.com

Abstract 

Gut microbiota is widely considered to be one of the most important components to maintain balanced homeostasis. Looking forward, probiotic bacteria have been shown to play a signifcant role in immunomodulation and display antitumour properties. Bacterial strains could be responsible for detection and degradation of potential carcinogens and production of short-chain fatty acids, which afect cell death and proliferation and are known as signaling molecules in the immune system. Lactic acid bacteria present in the gut has been shown to have a role in regression of carcinogenesis due to their infuence on immunomodulation, which can stand as a proof of interaction between bacterial metabolites and immune and epithelial cells. Probiotic bacteria have the ability to both increase and decrease the production of anti-infammatory cytokines which play an important role in prevention of carcinogenesis. They are also capable of activating phagocytes in order to eliminate early-stage cancer cells. Application of heat-killed probiotic bacteria coupled with radiation had a positive infuence on enhancing immunological recognition of cancer cells. In the absence of active microbiota, murine immunity to carcinogens has been decreased. There are numerous cohort studies showing the correlation between ingestion of dairy products and the risk of colon and colorectal cancer. An idea of using probiotic bacteria as vectors to administer drugs has emerged lately as several papers presenting successful results have been revealed. Within the next few years, probiotic bacteria as well as gut microbiota are likely to become an important component in cancer prevention and treatment.

Introduction 

Cancer is considered as one of the most signifcant causes of death. The treatment of tumors has received much attention in the last years; however, the number of people sufering neoplastic syndrome is still increasing. Thus, researchers are trying to face this process searching for innovative therapies and prophylaxis. Despite the fact that cancer risk indisputably depends on genetic factors, immunological condition of the organism plays a considerable role in it, that being closely associated with probiotic bacteria and commensal bacterial fora presented mainly in the digestive tract. Probiotic strains, inter alia Bifdobacterium, or Lactobacillus, widely present in commonly consumed fermented milk products, are known to have various benefcial efects on health. To date, there is a plethora of studies investigating the correlation between intestinal microbiota and carcinogenesis which have been evaluated in this article. A growing body of research has been analyzed and reviewed for the potential application of probiotics strains in prevention and treatment of cancer. 

Probiotics and Cancer 

Goldin and Gorbach were among the frst to demonstrate the association between a diet enriched with Lactobacillus and a reduced incidence of colon cancer (40% vs. 77% in controls). Probiotics have been gaining much attention due to their ability to modulate cancer cell’s proliferation and apoptosis, investigated both in vitro and in vivo . Potential application of these properties in novel therapy could potentially be alternative to more invasive treatment such as chemotherapy or radiotherapy.

Mechanisms of Action 

A specifc mechanism associated with antitumor properties of probiotics remains unclear. Gut microbiota is engaged in a variety of pathways, which are considered to play a central role in that process. Primarily, probiotic bacteria play an essential role in the preservation of homeostasis, maintaining sustainable physicochemical conditions in the colon. Reduced pH caused inter alia by the excessive presence of bile acids in feces may be a direct cytotoxic factor afecting colonic epithelium leading to colon carcinogenesis. Regarding their involvement in the modulation of pH and bile acid profle, probiotic bacteria such as L. acidophilus and B. bifdum have been demonstrated to be a promising tool in cancer prevention.

Probiotic strains are also responsible for maintaining the balance between the quantity of other participants of natural intestinal microfora and their metabolic activity. Putrefactive bacteria, such as Escherichia coli and Clostridium perfringens naturally present in the gut, has been proven to be involved in  production of carcinogenic compounds using enzymes like b-glucuronidase, azoreductase, and nitroreductase. Some preliminary research conducted by Goldin and Gorbach in the late 1970s have proven consumption of milk fermentation products to have a benefcial efect on the increase in the number of L. acidophilus in rat’s gut, which subsequently resulted in a reduction of putrefactive bacteria and decrease in the level of harmful enzymes. Several subsequent studies confrmed the positive infuence of the probiotic strains on the activity of bacterial enzymes implicated in the tumor genesis both in humans and rodents. It is worth noting that there is considerable ambiguity among the gathered data; nevertheless, results concerning glucuronidase and nitroreductase are in general consistent. However, whether these processes afect cancer rates in humans is yet to be investigated [39]. Another cancer-preventing strategy involving probiotic bacteria, chiefy Lactobacillus and Bifdobacillus strains, could be linked to the binding and degradation of potential carcinogens. Mutagenic compounds associated with the increased risk of colon cancer are commonly found inunhealthy food, especially fried meat. Ingestion of Lactobacillus strain by human volunteers alleviated the mutagenic efect of diet rich in cooked meat, which resulted in a decreased urinary and fecal excretion of heterocyclic aromatic amines (HAAs). Supplementation with dietary lactic acid bacteria has shown to downregulate the uptake of 3-amino-1-methyl-5H-pyrido (4,3-β) indole (TrpP-2) and its metabolites in mice. Furthermore, many in vitro studies have been conducted, demonstrating the ability of diferent probiotics strains to either bind  or metabolize  mutagenic compounds such as HAAs,  nitrosamines , afatoxin B1, and others: mycotoxins, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and phthalic acid esters (PAEs). In some cases investigation revealed the correlation of these properties with the reduction of mutagenic activities presented by the aforementioned compounds. It is worth highlighting that the substantial part of a current knowledge on the phenomenon discussed above is largely based on in vitro studies. All these results should be interpreted with caution, according to the variations of  factors such as pH, occurring at in vivo conditions, which can potentially alter the efciency of binding or degradation of the mutagens . Many benefcial compounds produced and metabolized by gut microbiota have been demonstrated to play an essential role in maintaining homeostasis and suppressing carcinogenesis. Specifc population of gut microbiota are dedicated to production of short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) such as acetate, propionate, and butyrate as a result of the fermentation of fber-rich prebiotics. Except for their principal function as an energy source, SCFA have also been proven to act as signaling molecules afecting the immune system, cell death, and proliferation  as well as the intestinal hormone production and lipogenesis, which explains their crucial role in epithelial integrity maintenance. Although lactic acid bacteria are not directly involved in SCFA production, certain probiotic strains of Bifidobacteria and Lactobacilli can modulate the gut microbiota composition and consequently affect the production of SCFA . Butyrate, produced by species belonging to the Firmicutes families (Ruminococcaceae, Lachnospiraceae, and Clostridiaceae) has been proven to promote apoptosis and inhibit proliferation in cancer cells cultured in vitro  and remains the most investigated of SCFAs. Colorectal cancer is strongly correlated with decreased levels of SCFA and SCFA-producing bacteria dysbiosis. Administration of bacterial strain Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens MDT-1, (known for their high production of butyrate) in mouse model of colon cancer, inhibited progression of tumor development, affecting also the reduction of β-glucuronidase and increasing the immune response .

More recent evidence suggests modulation of SCFAproducing bacteria by dietary intervention with fermentable fibers as a possible colorectal cancer treatment. A more recent study on mice demonstrated amelioration of polyposis in CRC (colorectal cancer) after increasing SCFA-producing bacteria after introduction of probiotic diet. Previously investigated application of synbiotic combination of B. lactis and resistant starch in rat-azoxymethane model has been proven to protect against the development of CRC, which was correlated with increased SCFA production. Interestingly, neither B. lactis nor prebiotic were sufficient to achieve that effect alone. This and some previous assays suggest that prebiotic activity of fiber-enriched diet, projecting on the level of beneficial bacteria, is promising strategy to prevent CRC.

 

Lactic acid bacteria have been receiving much attention due to its contribution to immunomodulation correlated with either suppression or regression of carcinogenesis. This phenomenon is the result of multidimensional activity involving interaction between the bacteria or their metabolites with the immune and epithelial cells. Consequentially, probiotic strains have the ability to both increase and decrease the production of antiinflammatory cytokines as well as modulate secretion of prostaglandins, which altogether projects on suppression of carcinogenesis. Another strategy involves activation of phagocytes by certain probiotic strains, leading to direct elimination of early-stage cancer cells . For a detailed review, see a comprehensive elaboration recently published in Nature summarizing the mechanisms engaging microbiota in immune homeostasis and disease. It has been demonstrated that some probiotics strains of Lactobacilli have been proven to suppress gastric-cancer-related H. pylori infections. Another study conducted on patients with persistent human papillomavirus virus (HPV) showed an enhanced clearance of HPV and cervical cancer precursors after daily consumption of probiotics for 6 months.

Probiotics in Cancer 

Therapy In recent years, there has been growing interest in the possible application of probiotics as a part of combination therapy with conventional treatment of cancer. An early but controlled and comparative study on 223 patients carried out in 1993 showed that combination therapy including radiation and treatment with heat-killed L. casei strains (LC9018) and improved the induction of immune response mechanisms against cancer cells thereby enhancing tumor regression in patients with carcinoma of the uterine cervix. Research on azoxymethane-induced CRC mice model treated by the probiotic mix composed of seven diferent strains of lactobacilli, bifdobacteria, and streptococcus demonstrated suppression of colon carcinogenesis due to modulation of mucosal CD4+ T polarization and changes in the gene expression. Furthermore, latest experiment investigating the efects of B. infantis administration in CRC rat model demonstrated a considerable attenuation of chemotherapy-induced intestinal mucositis correlated with decreased level on proinfammatory cytokines (IL-6, IL-1β, TNF-α) and increased CD4+ CD25+ Foxp3+ T regulatory cell response. Over and above that, two seminal papers published in Science highlighted the signifcant role played by gut microbiota in the immune response to cancer treatment. Disruption of the microbiota in mice was made evident by a decreased immune response and thereby tumor resistance for either cyclophosphamide or oxaliplatin therapy. As a result of these fndings, probiotic bacteria have been gaining traction as a crucial component in successful cancer immunotherapy. 

The most recent experiments on mice have illustrated the key role of gut microbiota (Bacteroides and Bifdobacterium) in anti-PD-L1 (Programmed death-ligand 1) and anti-CTLA-4 (cytotoxic T lymphocyte-associated protein 4) therapies. Immunomodulatory efect was exhibited in intensifed activation of dendritic cells and also promotion of antitumor T cell response. Essentially, Sivan et al.  observed a similar improvement of tumor control as a result of Bifdobacterium treatment alone compared to anti–PD-L1 therapy, whereas combination of both strategies was suffcient to nearly eliminate tumor outgrowth. These groundbreaking results indicate that administration of probiotics appears to be a promising strategy in maximizing the efciency of cancer immunotherapy.

Cohort Studies 

Several cohort studies have revealed the correlation between the consumption of dairy products and the risk of colon cancer. Some of these fndings appear useful in drawing conclusions concerning the role of probiotic bacteria in carcinogenesis, taking into account certain groups of previously investigated dairy products such as fermented milk products with a special emphasis on yogurt. There is still considerable ambiguity among studies, summarized in Table 3. In contrast to that uncertainty, a recent study conducted in 2012 produced a meta-analysis including nineteen cohort studies which demonstrated an association between consumption of dairy products (except cheese) and a decreased colorectal cancer risk . Another noteworthy approach investigating the infuence of dairy products on post-diagnostic CRC survival clearly indicates positive correlation between the high dairy intake and the lower risk of death. A key problem with the majority of the cohort studies mentioned above is that they covered general dairy intake, including high-fat components such as cream and cheese, suspected of carcinogenic properties due to their ability to increase bile acid levels in the colon . Moreover, research tends to focus on anticancer compounds such as calcium or vitamin D, without paying special attention to probiotics. Therefore, the frst innovative cohort study conducted in 2011 by Pala et al. on 45,241 subjects proved a signifcant association between single probiotic-rich product intake (yogurt) and decreased colon cancer risk. Similar approaches should be conducted on large cohorts, investigating probiotics’ intake from natural sources (such as yogurt and other fermented dairy products) as well as supplements, in order to reveal their efect on cancer risk.

Probiotics in Treatment and Prophylaxis 

Utilization of the recombinant probiotic strains as a delivery system for various therapeutic molecules such as drugs, as well as cytokines, enzymes, or even DNA  is quite recent and exceptional idea that could be successfully applied for colorectal cancer treatment. Probiotic bacteria are indispensable as vectors due to their wide range of tolerance to the environment of gastrointestinal tract co-occurring with their natural capability of colonizing the mucosal surface followed by prolonged residence maintaining their protective properties . The innovative concept of a “bio drug” relies on oral administration of genetically modifed probiotics allowing a direct delivery of the  therapeutic components to the intestinal mucosa. Regarding low costs, simple technology, and procedure of the treatment, this strategy has a great potential to be widely used in prevention and treatment of various disorders. In several independent studies on rodents, intragastric application of recombinant strains of Lactobacillus lactis expressing anti-infammatory compounds (cytokines, IL-10, human interferon-beta, or antioxidants) has been shown to ameliorate the intestinal infammation and demonstrated cytoprotective efect. In another approach, application of Lactococcus lactis expressing catalase has been proven to decrease the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) such as H2O2, reducing colonic damage, and infammation, consequently projecting on tumor invasion and proliferation.

 More recent study investigating multiple strategies of inhibition of the infammatory-related carcinogenesis with diferent combination of probiotic vectors expressing antioxidant enzymes (catalase, superoxide dismutase) or IL-10 (produced as cDNA or in expression system inducible by stress—SICE) has shown these strains as agents causing signifcant changes of the immune response as well as preneoplastic lesions or even causing the entire inhibition of tumor development.

A plethora of studies reported potential application of the probiotic expression systems as vaccines, demonstrating stimulation of the adaptive immune system response against the pathogens. A number of experiments investigating application of genetically engineered probiotics expressing human papillomavirus E7 oncoprotein or the treatment of cervical cancer have shown that in contrast to the traditional polyvalent vaccines, which have preventive properties only on the development of the disease, “probiotic vaccination” has been demonstrated to have both protective (stimulating immunological response) and therapeutic efects (tumor regression). Pre-immunization with E7-displaying lactococci signifcantly enhanced the antitumor efect of a following treatment with adenovirus .

Studies on TC-1 tumor murine model have shown that therapeutic efect can be enhanced by co-administration of Lactobacillus lactis capable of expressing oncoprotein E7 and immunostimulatory compounds, such as interleukin-12. Prophylactic administration of the vaccine in healthy individuals conferred to resistance to subsequent administration of lethal levels of tumor cell line TC-1, even after the second induction, resulting in 80 to 100% survival rate. Treatment of tumor-bearing mice with recombined probiotic caused regression of palpable tumors,correlated with the increased antitumor cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) immunoresponse.

Most recent evidence proposes the utilization of probiotics in the delivery of tumor-associated antigens (TAAs) as an orally administrated vaccine, based on a recently reported prosperous approach with Bifidobacterium expressing Wilms’ tumor 1 (WT1) protein.

Occurrence of hypoxic and neurotic areas among solid cancer tissues gives rise to the opportunity of utilization of a specifc tendency of certain probiotic strains for selective localization and proliferation in anaerobic environment . This phenomenon was further investigated in rodents, leading to the evaluation of direct anticancer treatment using Bifdobacteria as a delivery vehicle for specifc drugs such as cytosine deaminase or angiostatins  or even in gene therapy.

The most important limitation of abovementioned strategies lies in the fact that genes for antibiotic resistance, commonly used as selective marker in the procedure of cloning, could be potentially transferred to resident intestinal microbiota by probiotic delivery vectors. Finding an alternative, secure selection marker for cloning in therapeutic strains still remains a challenging area in this feld .

Conclusions 

This paper has given an account of the role played by gut microbiota in cancer prevention and treatment. It is noteworthy that until now most of these innovative methods mentioned above have only been investigated in animal models. Clinical tests of this strategy are expected to raise a possibility of utilizing probiotic bacteria as comprehensive drug-delivery vectors for non-invasive cancer treatment in humans. Taken together, a growing body of literature had highlighted a role of probiotic balance in maintenance of widely understood homeostasis, projecting on successful cancer therapy. The evidence from latest studies points towards the idea of possible implementation of probiotics in cutting-edge cancer therapies. Future investigations on the current topic are therefore necessary in order to validate these fndings and establish therapeutic strategies. This could conceivably lead to a breakthrough in various felds of medicine not only supporting immunotherapy in cancer treatment or elaboration and production of an innovative vaccines, but also improving drug delivery in other bowel diseases while preventing and mitigating infammation at the same time.